EdNA - Education Network Australia
Natcom 3
Australian Cultural Forum Model

Download the rtf version of this file.

Australian Cultural Forum Model

Overview of the idea
This model for telecommunications activity involves students engaging in structured exchanges with peers and prominent Australians about social issues. Host classes will define a social issue and manage an exchange of ideas in three stages between groups of classes. The term, forum, is used here to capture the activities where an exchange of ideas occurs via telecommunications around one topic or issue. For a forum, participants will engage in offline research and preparation processes and then participate in exchanges around 3 questions, one of which is posed in each stage. The model describes a calendar of forums and a management process to encourage teachers to host and manage forums. The model is sufficiently flexible to incorporate a variety of online tools and processes. This model has been adapted from the Global Youth Forum Project of oz-TeacherNet.

The model has two defining attributes. It enables teachers to underpin the design of the debates/exchanges with the curriculum models from their syllabuses; for example, the social investigations process or an information literacy process. This provides a more precise curriculum fit and will appeal to teachers who are required to incorporate such processes into curriculum implementation. The model also incorporates the use of existing published educational resources into a project. For example, CD resources and information Kits like Discovering Democracy omit the interactions that help students engage in the ideas which have been collated in the resource. This project model helps teachers identify how to extend the use of resources into a set of learning experiences.

The model contains many of the attributes of the Natcom models described in accompanying documents. It identifies the model components which are central to the activities of the stakeholder groups, teachers, students, project mangers and minor stakeholders.

From this model, a variety of curriculum projects might be developed, though it is likely they will be more correctly viewed as episodes of forums in a calendar of forum events. Teachers understand episodes as examples of a forum in a calendar of forums.

The choice and nature of social and cultural problems is a paramount consideration of this model. The model requires that teachers redevelop a topic into a solvable but open-ended social question and that they scaffold students' activities through a problem solving process. The technological environment in which this model is set creates a natural context for some problems and the model is an opportunity for teachers in key learning areas to help students confront the impact of technology, particularly communications technologies on the communities which surround their key learning area.

An example of an Australian Cultural Forum episode
A host school might approach the Forum coordinator to host a forum around the issue of telecommunications access for tertiary opportunities to country areas.

The coordinator and teacher would negotiate the open-ended topic structure into a problem and pose three questions likely to stimulate exchanges between schools.

The episode would be added to the Forum calendar to encourage schools to participate.

A web page would be developed so teachers and students can access and use relevant resources currently available to Australian schools. This web site is an important teachers resource and provides pedagogical as well as curriculum knowledge to accompany the subject matter.

Literacy and numeracy elements would be negotiated and developed onto this web collection.

A professional development program may be initiated for teachers intending to participate.

The host school would conduct the debate in three stages by email or a web forum. It is likely that the first stage would involve collection and analysis of data, the second involve the formation and communication of student positions, the third might involve interactions with community groups and online guests, helping students to redevelop positions and strengthen arguments.

The host school would close the debate.

Further examples

The Australian Federation of Societies for Studies of Society and Environment (AFSSSE) have developed a curriculum project based on this model that suits this purposes.
Download Full Project Description

Oz-TeacherNet have begun testing this model in the Global Youth Forums Project. Some examples are now available.
http://rite.ed.qut.edu.au/oz-teachernet/

Rationales
In order to participate in a future modern society and to help progress Australia's leading information industry position, students need to develop the skills of debating Australia's identity and understanding the cultural, social, industrial, technical and information issues confronting the emerging new structures. Connectivity between people is not a neutral cultural development. There is now a range of new issues to be considered and existing issues need to be redressed through a new lens. Embedded in all curriculum documents is the need to develop skills for informed debate, to have a broader awareness of the views of stakeholders and to think "outside of the box". Such processes are integral to the attributes for modern citizenry where capitalising on the new communications systems and new media is core. This model provides teachers with strategies to enable students to participate in online debates though the medium which is shaping the issues, and to confront issues which have gained significance because Australia is building its information economy within the global context. This model therefore has potential to redefine the curriculum of many key learning areas.

Telecommunications curriculum projects provide an authentic audience for students thinking, questions and debates. Telecommunications provides students with access to audiences outside of the school and provides access to the opinions of others, a wide variety of sources of ideas and background information. In this model in particular, debates with others lead to higher levels of thinking and responsibility for arguments. Teachers and students can work together to develop ideas into debates and to publish ideas to a critical peer audience. Interaction about ideas is the link missing in the static educational resources usually published for school use. This project model adds value to the resources and provides authentic audience for student ideas.

Engaging in subject matter and synthesising ideas through debate and argument are core curriculum processes embedded in all KLA's. Most curriculum documents articulate the processes students might practice. This model enables teachers to insert different curriculum models to the discussion process; for example, the social investigations approach, information literacy approach and various problem solving approaches. The model also encourages constructivist approaches, problem solving, project work and student-centred learning approaches to be built into curriculum activities. It enables teachers to try different communication and discussion strategies and to explore different ways of integrating online activity into learning experiences. It also provides a chance for project designers to try different approaches to enticing teachers to participate with their classes. Further, the open-ended nature of the model, from which specific events and projects will be built, enables exploration of different technologies such as text, voice and video chat, bulletin boards, email lists and conferencing systems. The model's flexibility then enables different subject areas to make use of this model while implementing their particular curriculum models and subject matter.

This project model design provides a pedagogical model for teachers to experience within a supportive professional atmosphere. By participating in this project idea, teachers are undertaking on-the-job professional development and have an audience for their questions and reflections. The project is an exemplary model of curriculum practice. The project model incorporates a number of structures which are specifically aimed at teachers undertaking the curriculum development process and broadening their understanding of the impact of learning technology on subject matter, curriculum interpretations and pedagogical opportunities.

Project model components

In this description, the project structure is unravelled as structures for students, teachers and project managers.

  Project model components

Students structures

Core online idea Students participate in a series of structured debates around three questions of increasing cognitive depth. The first question encourages students to gather information, make connections between views and prompts students to understand the information in the context of the original problem. These interpretations are shared. In the second question, students are encouraged to argue perspectives and defend their arguments as students critique the responses of others. In the third question, an online guest or an event in which arguments are represented to a community group, cause students to redevelop opinions and draw to conclusions which may then be published.
Core curriculum idea Students will engage in higher order thinking if they debate their interpretations of social issues with a known audience. The interactions require students to defend arguments, probe ideas and draw conclusions. The issues of the debates require students to confront the role of communications technologies on their curriculum area and how they participate in debate. This project models the potential for communications technology to enable citizens to participate in public debates and influence global agendas.
Curriculum processes In each episode, or forum, students will undertake the curriculum processes adopted by the host teacher. For some forums, the information literacy cycle might determine the curriculum processes and these will be incorporated into the forum stages. In other forums, a social investigations model might determine how local, online data, opinion development and communication are incorporated into forum stages.
Online content students engage in The site for each episode will provide access to web-published information around the topics, as well as analyses of information and resources published in other media. In phase one, as student sources of ideas are published, a web tool could collect students' resources and their commentaries on them.

Teachers will determine the content that students engage in, though the choice of topic, the framing of questions in the stages of debate and the curriculum or investigation model which underpins the process.

Online experts In the third phase of the forum, forum managers will be encouraged to include online experts, prominent citizens and community groups in dialogue with students. These people might offer critique of student's opinions, engage in the debates at the same level as the students, play a devil's advocate role or introduce new perspectives into discussions.
Peer community Students can help other students develop arguments, supply opinions and references to ideas of others, critique arguments and be supportive at all stages of the debate.
Online content Students' build Students references and reviews of resources can be added to the site through use of smart online tools which collate students submissions. Archiving discussion lists and forums provide access to students ideas during and after a forum has been conducted. The site should also allow schools to submit links to their locally-published resources. Tools may need to be developed to enable this process to occur without the project coordinator or forum manger needed to manually edit web pages.


Teachers' components

Core activity idea Teachers help students participate in a staged debate about a key issue via various telecommunications tools. Students and teachers can cooperatively develop arguments and participate in debate. Locally, students can undertake the curriculum processes in their KLA and construct products for local assessment and other purposes. The teacher hosting the forum, can help students frame the issue and questions or can undertake this task themselves. Participating teachers and their classes respond to the initiatives of the host class.
Procedures For host teachers, different procedures are required to initiate a forum. These hosts contact the forum coordinator and outline an idea. The coordinator and host teacher negotiate the problem within the topic, and develop the three phases of the project. The host teacher may develop a web page to assist teachers and students to use online and other resources. Specific pedagogical ideas might be shared through this site as well as links to numeracy and literacy ideas. The forum is added to the calendar of events and an advertising campaign is put into place.

Participating teachers might choose an event from a calendar or because they are attracted by email and other information that drew their attention to the forum. They would join the teachers' list for the forum as a registration process and may subscribe their students email address to the students' list or threaded discussion. Welcoming messages might be exchanged, as preparation to participate is occurring in local classrooms. Teachers then follow the prompts of the project coordinator and forum host to engage their students in the exchanges.

Teachers may engage in online professional development activities as part of their preparation or as part of ongoing support while the project is occurring. A debrief includes encouraging teachers to add activities and student's publishing to the site.

Professional community or professional development activity Teachers have an email community which serves as a register of participants as well as a place to seek help, share ideas and conduct professional development events. Occasionally online professional development events are hosted on this list.
Numeracy companion A companion reminds teachers of the numeracy opportunities in investigations. In particular, statistical opportunities and the links between generalisations, numeracy and public understanding will be highlighted in arguments and processes. This advice might occur interactively on the teachers list as the forum proceeds or may be derived from a web site of previously contributed ideas.
Literacy walk A literacy walk may be included as part of the teachers resources, raising for teachers the issues of conducting literacy activities in online media and in helping teachers identify the language and genres which are incorporated in the processes of online debate and local classroom work.
Online content Online content for teachers includes links to professional information about resources, teaching techniques and curriculum processes. This may be delivered through a web site or through an online course conducted by email for participating teachers.
Online experts The project coordinator and host teacher may invite online guests to talk on the teachers list before or while they are working with students.
Peer community The teachers' peer community on this project is hosted by an email list and contains pedagogical experts and teachers. Teacher's work may also showcased in events and through the web site.

Project managers components

Technical tools The tools for this model can be applied at two levels: across all forums and within each forum. The project manager would be responsible for developing and maintaining the tools that allow collections of forums to be hosted by volunteers and groups.

A forums web site would provide advice to teachers wishing to host and be involved in forums generally. This site would contain the online content common to all forums.

A forums calendar tool would enable teachers to register interest in a forum, negotiate the forum description with the project managers and eventually make the descriptions publicly viewable on the calendar.

An archived teachers list acts to announce forums, conduct some professional development and seek new host teachers. A tool for easy list registration is important.

Tools which enable teachers to add resources and links to the forum web site is important to engender community participation and to remove the load from the project coordinator.

Some forums may require access to a threaded web-discussion facility, a web-based chat room or other synchronous and asynchronous spaces. These might be hosted at forum project level and made accessible through each forum's web page.

Each forum may require web space where teachers can build a web site to collate resources for that particular forum. The host teacher's school or a community group offering free web space could provide this.

Each forum may require a teacher and student list to conduct the conversations, professional development and debates. A tool for easy list registration is important.

Management tools The project manager uses technical tools to enhance organisational processes. It is important to have processes in place to attract forum hosts, negotiate forum descriptions, advertise forums in teacher communities, develop web pages without manual HTML editing and upload resources from teachers. Management tools include processes to archive forums and convert them to resources for later use and to collect feedback about the conduct of forums.

The professional development process requires a number of processes and tools and may range from face-to-face workshops, online events and courses, mixed programs of professional development, web sites and online tutorials. Teacher content provides the bulk of professional development materials. Helping teachers participate in a forum is a professional development activity and tools may help project managers encourage and support participating teachers.

Human resources This model requires a project manager to work with forum hosts, develop the overall web site and negotiate with programmers to develop tools which automate the process and extend the projects structure and reach. Forum hosts may be volunteers from schools, groups within professional associations and other community groups interested in helping students develop debates with other students.
Development of the model As episodes of forums are hosted, the coordinator would gather knowledge about forum design, use of tools to provoke dialogue, supporting hosts and conducting professional development. This would enable the development of forums to take account of users needs as they develop and mature.
Natcom 3 Home
Introduction
Rationale
The Models
Understanding Project Models
Other Papers
Associations Proposals
Natcom Home
Natcom Associations
Copyright
ACCE